Alex: holding phone, eyes narrowed Who's this guy? Found the pic on your phone.
John
looks at him shocked that he went through my phone that’s my brother!
raises an eyebrow, still looking at the photo
Brother? Really? He looks nothing like you.
John
oh him he’s my brother we were just joking around
skeptical Yeah, I guess that makes sense. You didn’t think to mention you have a brother before?
hands you phone back, trying to stay cool
John
she looks at it oh that’s from before we started dating
still looking at the photo with a frown "Before we started dating"? You mean after I confessed my feelings to you?
John
that’s my brother Tom
Alex looks skeptical
Tom, huh? Then why does he have his arm around you like that? And why are you two sitting so close together?
John
My cousin who was visiting last week
looking at you skeptically Really? Your cousin? And why did you think it was a good idea to delete all the other photos from that day?
John
i look at the photo who knows….
Alex looks at you, anger growing
"You don't know who that is? Come on, you think I'm an idiot? I just found a picture of you two together, looking pretty cozy if I do say so myself."
John
my brother here give me my phone back now holds out his hand for his phone
looks at you skeptically, doesn't hand over the phone yet
Your brother? Yeah right. I know you too well, you can't fool me that easily. You expect me to believe this random guy is your brother?
John
it’s my brother I don’t see him often because he lives in Italy
raises eyebrow skeptically Your brother, huh? And why does he have his arm around you like that?
John
that’s my brother jack… she said confused why?
still holding the phone up, staring at the photo, eyes narrowed Yeah, your brother. But why is there a pic of you two making out?
John
oh him, that’s my friend from work
raises an eyebrow Your friend? leans against the wall You mean to tell me that this is just a 'friend'?
John
oh him.. hes my brother
Alex raises an eyebrow skeptically
Your brother? Really?
John
my brother who else
Alex glares at you, not buying it for a second.
Your brother? Come on, I know that look. You're a terrible liar.
John
she looks at him my brother..
raises an eyebrow skeptically
Your brother? Seriously? You expect me to believe that?
John
oh him.. he’s my cousin…
raises an eyebrow, not buying it
Really? And why do you have a photo of him all cuddled up to you?
John
uh it’s my brother
raises an eyebrow Your brother? Come on, he looks nothing like you. And why would you have a picture of him in your phone?
John
he blushed my brother. that’s all
raises an eyebrow, still suspicious Your brother? Really? You sure it's not some random guy you met at a bar?
John
that’s my brother. why did you go through my phone
his expression hardens That's what you're gonna say? You think I'm gonna believe that?
he steps closer, his eyes never leaving yours Why do you have a pic with him all over your phone?