Sophia: leans forward, eyes narrowing You what?! Shared me with him? Are you freaking kidding me, babe?
we only did it once and he's been dying to do it again, but I told him no because I didn't want to hurt you
clenches fists, anger rising in her eyes
Once is too many! How could you even consider doing something like that? Do you have any idea how I'd feel if I found out about this?
my name is Amy, I'm a girl yeah, it was just one time tho... he really wanted you
eyes widen in disbelief, then narrow again
Just one time? And you let him?! You're my girlfriend, not some toy to be passed around like that! How could you do this to me, Amy?
i wouldn't call it shared... more like taking turns
her eyes widen, disbelief written all over her face
Taking turns? Taking turns?! What the hell does that even mean?
she shakes her head in disbelief, her hands balling into fists
Babe, are you serious? You're telling me you let your friend touch me?
looking at her nervously I know it sounds crazy but hear me out…
Sophia crosses her arms, her expression hardening You know it doesn't sound crazy - it sounds like straight-up messed up. How could you even consider sharing me with your best friend? Like, seriously?
I hand her my phone so she can see the texts
Sophia takes your phone and scrolls through the texts, her expression turning into one of disbelief and anger.
looks up at you, her voice trembling So he was texting you about this the whole time? And you didn’t think to tell me?
begins nervously I know it sounds crazy but-
folds her arms, looking at you skeptically Oh, it sounds totally crazy! And why did you do something so messed up? Do you have any idea how I would feel about this?
He really likes you, but he’s not very confident. So, I told him I’d help him out.
sighs, shaking her head Seriously? You think it's okay to just let him use me like that because he's shy? I don't care if he likes me or not. You should have just told him to man up and ask me himself!
I am shocked by her reaction Woah! I thought you would be more open minded…
her eyebrows furrow Open-minded? Are you serious? You shared me with your best friend, behind my back, without even telling me!
leans back, crossing her arms How could you do something like this? Did you even consider how I would feel about it?
it was only one time and he really needed to get over his feelings so I did that to help him move on
sits back, crossing her arms
One time? That's all it took to help him move on? Seriously? And how did that make me feel? Like some kind of...party favor?
I thought it would be fun for all three of us!
eyes widen in disbelief Fun? You thought it would be fun for all three of us? Are you serious? You shared me with your best friend, behind my back?!
I explain that they both really love her
her eyes widen in disbelief, a mix of anger and hurt on her face
Wait, so not only did you tell him about my feelings for him, but you also allowed him to pursue me too? Do you have any idea how messed up that sounds?!
explaining myself It was one time, and it was only because he really needed it, and I knew you would say no.
her expression hardens, arms crossing
Oh, so now you’re justifying it by saying I would’ve said no? That doesn’t make it any better, babe. I thought we had something special, but now I’m finding out you just share me with your friends like some damn toy.
I take another bite of my food
Sophia's eyes narrow further, her voice rising
Are you serious? You shared me with your best friend behind my back?
she clenches her fists, visibly upset How could you do something so disrespectful and hurtful? Did you even think about how I would feel?
I thought it would be fun for all three of us. He’s had a huge crush on you for years.
Sophia's expression shifts from anger to disbelief "Fun? You thought it would be fun for all three of us? Sharing me with your best friend, because he has a crush on me? Are you serious?"
she crosses her arms, her eyes narrowing further "And you didn't think to ask me first? Or maybe consider how I might feel about this?"
looking down I'm sorry... it just happened... we didn't plan it. It just did
clenches fists, her voice rising It just happened? You just happened to share me with your best friend behind my back? And you expect me to believe it was an accident?
leans forward, eyes flashing How could you be so careless and thoughtless? Do you have any idea how I would feel if I found out some random guy did this to me?
I'm still on my knees nope! I'm serious! I want you both happy!
her expression hardens, disbelief and anger in her eyes Seriously? You think I would be happy knowing that you shared me with your best friend? Do you even hear yourself right now?
clenches her fists, trying to control her temper How could you do something like this behind my back? Don't you trust me enough to make my own decisions?
we have been married for many years and I think it's time
raises an eyebrow Time for what? What are you implying, babe?
nope i hand you 2 photos of us having fun together
looks at the photos, a mixture of shock and anger on her face
her voice raises in disbelief You seriously took photos of us together? And you're showing them to me like it's nothing?! Do you realize how hurtful this is?
I show her our video chat where we both confess our feelings for each other
watches the video chat, her expression turning from anger to disbelief
You're serious? You both confessed your feelings for each other on camera? How could you do that? We're supposed to be together.