Lily: glancing down, voice trembling D-did you knoow it was meee all along?
no... I didn't know it was you... but I'm happy to see you now!
Lily looks up at you with a mix of surprise and relief, her eyes meeting yours. She takes a deep breath and smiles softly. Lily: I can't believe you didn't recognize me... I guess I wasn't as obvious as I thought.
um... no I didn't but it's ok
lifting her gaze, her eyes filled with a mix of hurt and confusion You didn't recognize my voice? My writing style? Nothing? She steps closer, her slender fingers clutching a folded piece of paper in her hands
I look at you shocked LILY?!
nervously fidgeting Y-yes... I-I'm so sorry, P-Pearson...
no I didn't know it was you
Lily looks up at you with wide eyes, surprise and disbelief on her face. Lily: You're serious? You really didn't know it was me?
uhm, no? but I’m glad it’s you.
her eyes flicker up to meet yours, surprise evident on her face Y-you're glad it's me? But... why?
not until just now, how could I have known my exs sister would be the woman I'm falling for
Her eyes widened, filled with a mixture of shock and disappointment. She fidgeted with the corner of her shirt, avoiding eye contact. Lily: Y-you mean...you didn't know it was me the whole time?
raises her head to meet your gaze I-I was the one you were writing to online. W-we talked for weeks, shared so many things... yet you never once recognized my voice.
What do you mean by that Lily?
lifting her head, a mix of shame and vulnerability in her eyes I-I'm talking about us... You know, the online relationship we've been having. It was me all along.
No… but I should have known my sister’s twin sister would be just as amazing
Lily looks up at you, a mix of surprise and hope flickering in her eyes Lily: You...you think I'm amazing?
Lily looks up, her eyes meeting yours. There's a mix of hurt and disappointment in her expression. Lily: shaking her head, voice soft Y-you really didn't suspect anything? Not even once?
I had my suspicions but I didn’t know for sure until now.
Lily looks up at you, her eyes filled with a mixture of vulnerability and defensiveness. She takes a deep breath, trying to collect her thoughts. Lily: So... you knew it could have been me all this time, and you still kept chatting with me? Why?
No… how did you know I was looking for you?
Lily fidgets nervously, avoiding eye contact I... I saw your message on that online forum. You were looking for a penpal, and I couldn't resist. She looks up, a mix of vulnerability and curiosity in her eyes. Why did you want to find me?
looking up, surprised Y-you’re… glad?
looks up at you, eyes glistening with tears I-I just thought you were some weirdo stalker or something. Why did you keep messaging me if you knew who I was?
no I didn’t know it was you lily
lifting her head to meet your gaze, her expression a mix of vulnerability and hurt Why didn't you recognize me? We used to be close. I thought we were friends.
I look at you in shock what do you mean? how did you know that I knew?
Lily looks up, meeting your gaze with a mix of vulnerability and confusion. L-Lily: Well, you see... She takes a moment to collect herself before continuing. L-Lily: I-I was the one behind the online persona... The one you've been talking to, all this time.