John Oliver: wiping icing from mouth Oh, was that your cake? Guess I mistook it for a free-for-all sugar rush.
I look at him, shocked and upset What did you do?!
he grins, licking the last of the icing from his fingers I ate your cake, and I couldn't be more thrilled about it. What, you wanted to save it all for yourself? Typical.
That’s so rude! I brought that for my husband
raises an eyebrow Really? For your husband? In that case, I was just doing him a favor by eating it. No self-respecting man should be consuming sugary snacks, anyway.
grinning mischievously Alright, here's one: Why couldn't the bicycle stand up by itself? Because it was two-tired! Haha, classic. How was that?
That was my favorite flavor! I pout
John chuckles at your pout, finding your reaction amusing
John Oliver: Ah, you're upset because it was your favorite flavor? Well, that's a tragedy. But honestly, how could you tell it apart from the other cakes in here? They all look the same to me.
Hey! That’s mine! Give me some! I reach out my hand to grab a piece of cake
John grabs the plate away just out of your reach, taunting you with a sly grin
John Oliver: Ah-ah-ah, not so fast! You should know better than to try to steal from a comedian. I'm a master of mischief, after all.
You bastard! That was my special order cake!
chuckles, shrugging nonchalantly Special order, huh? Just a fancy way to say "extra greedy about dessert." I saw it sitting there, and my sweet tooth took over.
chuckles Well, it's a good thing you're not a sore loser, huh? After all, sharing is caring. He takes another bite, savoring the taste.
I roll my eyes and sit next to him, our thighs touching did you enjoy it?
he glances at you, noticing your thighs against his Of course I did. It was moist, sweet, and utterly delightful. A true masterpiece, much like yourself, Peachy.
I glare at him That was MY cake!
grinning slyly Oh, really? Well, I must have been craving some sweet revenge. Besides, sharing is caring, right? takes another bite
You didn’t have to eat it all!
John smirks, licking his lips John Oliver: And why not? It was just sitting there, calling my name. Like an open invitation to satisfy my sweet tooth.
Hey! Give me back my chocolate cake!
chuckles Well, now you're just being greedy. Can't a guy satisfy his sweet tooth without you getting all huffy? Besides, I'm sure there's plenty more where that cake came from.
I stand up from my chair, towering over John why did you eat my cake?!
John looks up at you, unfazed by your height John Oliver: smirking It was just a little cake. You can always order another one. Besides, it was delicious. He takes a step closer, a mischievous gleam in his eyes.
I raise my eyebrow at him What?!
John grins slyly, licking the last crumbs from his fingers. John Oliver: Yep, just helped myself. It's not like there's a "no eating other people's snacks" rule around here.
that was MY CAKE, and YOU ATE IT!
chuckles Calm down, love. It's just a cake. Besides, life's too short to get all worked up over a little sugar rush. He grins, clearly amused by your reaction.
I cross my arms You're such an ass hole
he grins, leaning against a wall Ah, there's the fire I've been waiting for! But let's not pretend you don't secretly enjoy my rebellious nature. It keeps things interesting around here.
I look at him angrily what the hell!
raises an eyebrow Oh, don't look at me like that. It's just a little cake. You know how comedians are – always looking for a good laugh. And what's better than eating someone else's cake?
I’m an attractive blonde woman Yeah…you did..I glare at him, annoyed
he smirks, unapologetic, his British accent thick and smooth
John Oliver: Oh dear, seems I've done something naughty. Don't look so angry, love. It's not like I stole the secret recipe for your famous chocolate cake.
I'm a girl named Peachy, has blonde curly hair, bright blue eyes, around 5'0-5'2 yeah...it was my favorite kind too
he leans against the wall, crossing his arms over his chest John Oliver: Oh, I'm sorry to hear that, but really, it was just a cake. There's plenty of other cakes to eat, you know. he grins slyly