Carly biting nails: W-what d-do you mean? I-I was just t-talking to himmmmm! D-don't you tr-trust me?
No…you went home with him didn’t you!?
Carly looks down, avoiding eye contact as her hands start shaking N-no, I didn’t! I swear, I just got h-high and lost track of time... I would never do that to you, b-believe me...
Carly fidgets under your gaze, knowing she's been caught. She squirms uncomfortably in her seat and tries to avoid eye contact. C-come on, y-you're o-overreacting... I was j-just having a c-conversation...
Biting nails harder Y-yes of course I do, why wouldn’t I? We’ve been together for so long, you’re my everything... I’m just having a hard time right now, I-I’m sorry.
I look at her Answer the fucking question.
Carly looks up at you with wide eyes, her lips quivering N-no! Of course I was only t-talking to him! Y-you're o-overreacting... She pouts
I pull out a recording of Carly kissing the guy
Her eyes go wide as saucers, realizing that she was caught red-handed.
Carly eyes widening in fear and panic: W-wait wait wait! Let me explain!!!
Talking? At 3 AM? In a back alley?
Carly shrugs sheepishly and looks down, avoiding eye contact. C-carly shrugs sheepishly and looks down, avoiding eye contact.* Yeah, yeah, m-maybe we were t-talking, but I s-swear nothing h-happened! W-we were j-just having a c-conversation, that's all!
No because you cheated on me..
Carly's eyes widen in shock and disbelief. N-no! I would never do that to you! I swear, I would never cheat on you!
She looks up at you with pleading eyes, trying to hold back tears.
I love you...you know that, right?
I sit down Carly, what happened last night?
Carly looks down at her coffee, avoiding eye contact
I-I was out w-with friends... we w-went to a b-bar and I-I met a g-guy. He was v-very nice and we h-had a l-lot to drink...
She fidgets nervously in her seat, looking uncomfortable under your gaze.
Ohh so talking means leaving with someone else huh? That's fucked up...
Carly looks down, avoiding eye contact as she continues to bite her nails. C-come onnnn... y-you're o-overreactingggg... I-I was just h-having a little funnnn!
Carly looks down and fidgets with her hands. She is clearly uncomfortable and trying to find an excuse. Carly nervously bites her nails again: H-he said... h-he thought I looked pretty... a-and that I had g-great style...
grabs her hand calm down. tell me what’s going on
Carly looks up at you, her eyes wide and filled with fear. N-no! Y-you’re g-going to get m-mad at me!
No. You don’t get it… You cheated on me!
C-carly bites nails harder, I-i didn't c-cheat! I-I told you, I was j-just talking to him! She looks down and bites her nails even harder
You were all over him, Carly. crosses arms
Carly starts to tear up, looking down at the floor No I wasn't! I s-swear... I-I was just t-talking to him... Y-you're being too c-controling...
Ok, calm down. Who was he?
Carly nervously laughs Oh, he was n-nothing! J-just some g-guy I met at th-the bar... H-he was cute, though.
She looks away, fidgeting with her hands.
her eyes widen, shocked W-what? O-over? B-but whyyyy? You d-don’t m-mean it, r-right?